[Update: see below.]
According to Snopes, this photo is legit — it’s a Cherokee 180 N6487J that crashed into a tree during a forced approach near Meadowlake Airport in Colorado last month after the engine lost power (the pilot, who was the sole occupant, had no serious injuries).
The picture is circulating around the Internet because of the funny juxtaposition of a flight school sign and a small plane crashed into a tree behind it. However, American Aviation uses Cessnas as its primary trainers (and a Piper Arrow for complex training), and the PA-28-180 in the picture is registered to a real-estate company, so unless it was on a lease-back, it really has nothing to do with the flying school or flying lessons. Still, it is hard not to come up with funny captions …
I received an e-mail from Mark at Meadowlake Airport pointing me to the story on the airport’s web site. The story clears up a few points:
- The pilot was practicing night circuits (I’m surprised by that, since the crash happened at 5:30 pm, at a relatively southerly attitude, and official night doesn’t being until 30 minutes after sunset).
- The plane was a rental, but not from American Aviation (it just happened to crash into a tree near their entrance).
- The pilot suffered no injuries at all in the crash, but was slightly hurt climbing down from the tree.
- The plane hit power lines (visible in the picture) first during an attempt to glide to the runway, then ended up in the tree.
The tree probably did a good job dissipating the plane’s energy and saving the pilot. If it was already dark (say, because the sun had gone behind mountains), the power lines would have been awfully hard to see.
The most amazing thing about this picture is that the unfortunate pilot managed to find that tree to roost in. The trees around Meadowlake … of that size … are mighty few and far between.
A friend has a ranch about 5 miles due south of the airport, 11 miles east of the Colorado Springs city limit sign. Road directions to reach his ranch are as simple as, “Go Eats on Colorado 94 to the first tree and turn left.” The trees are really that far apart out there on the plains.
Glad he came out of it ok but it is a strange one.
That’s an absolutely prize-winning photo. And a good demonstration of the fact that you don’t need an especially good landing spot to survive an engine failure, as long as you maintain control of the aircraft at best glide speed.
Thanks, Aviatrix. That makes me think of the incident out of Buttonville a couple of years ago. A flight instructor took a family up for a site-seeing flight in a Cessna, failed to identify a carb icing problem, and lost her engine. She made up for that, though, with a brilliant landing from low altitude over Markham, which has no empty space to speak of — she found a bit of green on the front lawn of IBM Canada, flared the plane, and stalled it right over (and into) a tiny bunch of trees. Everyone walked away, with only minor scrapes (this is from memory, so apologies for any errors).